Eyebrow Pencils

I've tried various eyebrow pencils, all in the hopes of finding one that was cost-friendly, easy to apply and didn't look like I just Sharpie-ed my own eyebrows. I've tried eyebrow powders, eyebrow gels and eyebrow pencils in various brown - dark grey shades, hoping to match my black hair.
Here are my thoughts:

Rimmel London Eyebrow Pencil, Dark Brown

The Rimmel London Eyebrow Pencil is probably, if not the most popular drugstore eyebrow pencil. There's a limited shade range of 3 various browns (I've used 2 of them when my hair was dyed brown and lighter brown haha). It's a good pencil but not something I would use if I'm looking for something natural.

Price: 5/5

Quality: 4/5
Colour Selection: 2/5

Koji, Spring Heart Lasting Eyebrow Pencil

The Koji, Spring Heart Lasting Eyebrow Pencil only comes in 2 shades, Brown and Dark Brown. I've gone through 2 of these babies because they're so long-lasting and cheap. I haven't gone back to them because the texture (tip of the pencil) is hard and not easy to blend.

They go for approximately $5 CDN but you can only find them online (I buy mine from Sasa online)

Price: 5/5

Quality: 4/5

Colour Selection: 2/5

Etude House, Drawing Eyebrow Pencil #5 Gray
This line comes in 6 different colours.

The Etude House Drawing Eyebrow Pencil in #5 Gray was my holy grail pencil for 2 years, I finally found an affordable eyebrow pencil that was suitable for black hair! The colour payoff was strong and the pencil was smooth and easy to use. Not only that, it was also only $5-$6CDN! I purchased mine (total of 3 or 4) from eBay. 

The only complaint I have is that I found the formula is be a little oily, it's easy to apply too much (and look like you've Sharpie-ed your own eyebrows in) and I would need to set my eyebrows with a translucent powder.

Price: 5/5

Quality: 4/5

Colour Selection: 5/5

The FaceShop Lovely Me:Ex Design My Eyebrow in #5 Dark Grey
This line of eyebrow pencils come in 5 different colours.

The FaceShop Eyebrow pencil is what I've been wearing on a daily basis. I picked it up from my local FaceShop for about $4-$5 a year  or two ago. This eyebrow pencil also gives good colour payoff but it's not as strong as Etude House; which is better for me. I can easily apply this without worrying about looking like I just used Black Marker on my eyebrows.

I enjoy this formula better as well, I don't need to set this with a powder but I do find myself needing to reapply at the end of the day (maybe I just touch my face a lot), which I personally don't mind.  

Price: 5/5

Quality: 5/5

Colour Selection: 4/5